WrestleCrap is a professional wrestling website created by R. D. Reynolds and Merle Vincent, serving as a "hall of shame" for some of the worst gimmicks and storylines in professional wrestling history. The site is currently run by Reynolds, Blade Braxton and Justin Henry.
Type of site
|Created by||RD Reynolds|
|Registration||Message board only|
Reynolds and Vincent launched the site in April 2000, quickly developing a following among wrestling fans. After Vincent committed suicide in September 2000, Reynolds continued to run the site by himself. He shut the site down in 2001, claiming the high cost of running the site was responsible. It returned the following year, albeit without the backlog of past inductions.
In 2006, the site added several new writers and features.
WrestleCrap is also the title of a book written by the site's creators, with an introduction by John Tenta (ISBN 1-55022-584-7). In addition, Reynolds has co-authored The Death of WCW, with wrestling journalist Bryan Alvarez, and he co-wrote The WrestleCrap Book of Lists! with Braxton, released in late 2007. Currently, both Reynolds and Alvarez are featured columnists for British pro wrestling and MMA magazine Fighting Spirit.
In December 2016, the entire site archive was made available for users who made a one-time donation to the site, or supported the site on Patreon.
- WrestleCrap Inductions, new induction weekly with rotating classic inductions weekly. These have been written primarily by RD over the years, including currently, but a number of others have written them, with "Triple Kelly" Kelly Parmalee being the lead induction writer for several years. In 2012, a rotating cast of guest writers have penned inductions, with Reynolds fine-tuning them. This continues in the 2013 relaunch.
- WrestleCrap Radio/The RD and Blade Show, RD and Blade's take on recent events in the American wrestling scene. After ending the show in July 2012, RD and Blade reunited for The RD and Blade Show in 2013.
- Headlies, faux wrestling news stories in the style of The Onion.
- Jobber of the Week, where a random wrestling jobber is profiled by Blade or RD, most often Blade. WrestleCrap contributor Robert Q. Seidelman would sub for Blade on occasion but has not written a JOTW column since 2009 after starting up an unofficial spin-off for the worst in game shows.
- Someone Bought This, a look at some of the more ridiculous wrestling merchandise on sale. This segment often looks at eBay items placed for auction by various users.
- RD's Ramblings, comments on current events in pro wrestling and replies to the emails he receives.
- RD's Book & DVD Reviews
- Re-Writing the Book, a column, written by Jed Shaffer, that looks at fictional alternate universes in wrestling, for example "What if the Montreal Screwjob never happened?".
- It Came From YouTube, a weekly celebration of the most obscure, insane and sometimes brilliant wrestling related clips found on YouTube.
- Curtain Jerker, new for the 2013 relaunch, Justin Henry kicks off each weekday with a look at a topic in the world of wrestling, with the intent of creating debate and chatter among the site's readers.
- Power Crappings, new for the 2013 relaunch, a "bottom" 25 list of the worst storylines, gimmicks, news stories, and rumors in circulation at the time.
- Epic Tweets Through Wrestling History, new for the 2013 relaunch, Emerson Witner creates satirical, often ironic, tweets from wrestling personalities throughout time.
- The Meme Event, photos from Raw and SmackDown, crudely captioned by Justin Henry.
The Gooker Award is given each year to the worst gimmick, storyline, or event in wrestling in that year. The award is named after The Gobbledygooker, widely thought of as one of the most disastrous wrestling gimmicks of all time.
- 2000: David Arquette as the WCW World Heavyweight Champion.
- 2001: The Invasion.
- 2002: Katie Vick (Triple H/Kane feud).
- 2003: Al Wilson (Torrie Wilson/Dawn Marie feud).
- 2004: The 2004 Raw Diva Search.
- 2005: The Jim Ross firing storyline and colonoscopy skit.
- 2006: The WWE's exploitation of Eddie Guerrero's name and legacy after his death (Eddiesploitation).
- 2007: The Vince McMahon paternity storyline and the reveal of Hornswoggle as his son.
- 2008: Mike Adamle's stint in WWE.
- 2009: The Hornswoggle/Chavo Guerrero feud.
- 2010: TNA Impact!'s move to Monday nights.
- 2011: Michael Cole's antics throughout the year.
- 2012: Claire Lynch (AJ Styles/Christopher Daniels and Kazarian feud).
- 2013: Dixie Carter's heel turn.
- 2014 (co-winner): Vince McMahon's comments about "brass rings".
- 2014 (co-winner): The Bella Twins feud.
- 2015: The Rusev and Summer Rae/Dolph Ziggler and Lana feud.
- 2016: WrestleMania 32.
- 2017: Jinder Mahal as the WWE Champion.
- 2018: Crown Jewel.
The 2001 award was not revealed until 2003 due to WrestleCrap's closing in 2001.
Each year's Gooker Award, with the exceptions of 2001 and 2002, was determined by a poll of site visitors. The 2001 and 2002 awards were chosen by Reynolds, since he felt there was no competition those years. Vince McMahon's comments about "brass rings" actually won the 2014 poll, but Reynolds declared that, since the Bella Twins feud came a close second in the poll, he named the "brass ring" comments and the Bella Twins feud co-winners.
WrestleCrap Radio (2005–2012; 2015–present)
In August 2005, WrestleCrap introduced a podcast called WrestleCrap Radio. Typically Reynolds and columnist Blade Braxton discuss their personal lives, make jokes that may or may not relate to current wrestling (or wrestling at all), and rarely discuss news items from the wrestling industry. On occasion interviews with guests from within the wrestling industry were broadcast such as their interviews with Vince Russo and Lance Storm. Induction writer Triple Kelly was the unofficial reserve host, having won a co-host contest in 2007. As of May 2010, she has hosted the show twice. The regular podcasts ended with WrestleCrap Radio episode 249, released on July 13, 2012.
On August 20, 2015, to coincide with the 10 year anniversary of WrestleCrap Radio, a new episode of Reynolds and Blade's occasional RD and Blade Show podcast was instead revealed to be the surprise 250th episode of WrestleCrap Radio. Episode 251 was released ten days later on August 30, followed by two more episodes each in September and October.
- RD's TRIP... to the Grocery – Reynolds discusses various food items he comes across at the "foodmart". Occasionally, Braxton will host this segment, or either host will talk about going to a completely different place, such as RD's trip to Disney World. On rare occasions, this segment will even showcase celebrity trips to various locations, such as Jonny Fairplay's trip to a local Canteloupe Festival.
- Fan Fiction Theatre – Presented by Sir Alec Heineken (Braxton), this segment presents a reading of wrestling fan-fiction, which often involve graphic sexual encounters between the story's subjects.
- Obscure Wrestling News – Reynolds and Braxton discuss random news stories from the wrestling world.
- Question of the Week – Reynolds and Braxton (attempt to) answer a question that has been submitted by the listeners.
- TNA News – This segment involves discussion of TNA news but due to the incompetence of the correspondent, the segment rarely involves very little actual discussion of TNA, if any. The role of TNA correspondent has been described as something of a 'poisoned chalice', as the TNA correspondents invariably end up meeting an untimely demise, drawing comparisons to the Defence Against The Dark Arts Teacher position from the Harry Potter series of books. The TNA correspondent position was most recently held by C.S. Irwin, a man who acted in a similar manner to Horatio Caine from CSI: Miami. Despite breaking the record for the longest-running TNA correspondent in Wrestlecrap Radio history, previously co-held by Johnny Six and Mike Check, Irwin's segments supposedly garnered the lowest listener ratings of any part of the show. As a result of this, he was eventually taken away by The Ratings Reaper, an anthropomorphic personification similar to The Grim Reaper responsible for ushering anything with low ratings into the afterlife. The current TNA correspondent is Blade's mailman, The Honky Tonk mailman, a parody of pro-wrestler The Honky Tonk Man who reports outdated news using copies of the Wrestling Observer newsletter stolen from a customer on his route.
- Current Wrestling News – Reynolds and Braxton discuss WWE-related news.
- Blade Braxton's Weekly Wrestling Haiku – The longest-running segment on the show, Braxton reads a haiku he has composed, related to an event of that week's wrestling programming. This is almost always the final segment on the show.
- Call-Ins – Although not a segment per se, these are a weekly occurrence on the show. This involves various characters "calling in" to the show to ramble on about various topics, to the frustration of Reynolds and Braxton. The most common characters featured are "Gay Popeye" (Reynolds) and "Angry Jim Ross" (Braxton), among many others.
- "Wrestlecrap.com Site Info". Alexa Internet. Retrieved 2018-01-29.
- Bakon, Jun. "R.D. Reynolds Interview". Lethal Wrestling. Archived from the original on September 25, 2013. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Reynolds, RD (September 10, 2000). "Merle Vincent, 1972-2000". WrestleCrap. Archived from the original on September 26, 2013. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Cardno, James. "RD Reynolds". NZPWI. Archived from the original on September 25, 2013. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- "About Us". Fighting Spirit Magazine.
- Reynolds, RD (January 10, 2013). "Press Release: WrestleCrap.com, The World's Longest-Running Pro Wrestling Comedy Site, Relaunces". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Reynolds, RD (December 22, 2016). "The WrestleCrap Archives - Now Online and Available Via Patreon!". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Reynolds, RD (January 2, 2011). "David Arquette: 2000 Gooker Award Winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Reynolds, RD (September 2, 2016). "The InVasion: 2001 Gooker Award Winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Reynolds, RD (January 7, 2011). "Katie Vick: 2002 Gooker Award Winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Reynolds, RD (January 9, 2011). "Al Wilson: 2003 Gooker Award Winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Reynolds, RD (January 10, 2011). "The Diva Search: 2004 Gooker Award Winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Reynolds, RD (January 18, 2011). "The Sad Saga of Jim Ross: 2005 Gooker Award Winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Reynolds, RD (January 19, 2011). "Eddiesploitation: 2006 Gooker Award Winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Reynolds, RD (January 20, 2011). "Vince's Bastard Son: 2007 Gooker Award Winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Reynolds, RD (January 30, 2011). "Mike Adamle: 2008 Gooker Award Winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- RD Reynolds and Triple Kelly (January 31, 2012). "Hornswoggle vs. Chavo: 2009 Gooker Award Winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Reynolds, RD (October 5, 2016). "INDUCTION: The NEW Monday Night Wars: 2010 Gooker Award Winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Reynolds, RD (December 26, 2012). "All Things Michael Cole: The 2011 Gooker Award Winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Reynolds, RD (June 3, 2016). "Claire Lynch: The 2012 Gooker Award Winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Reynolds, RD (January 20, 2014). "Induction: Heel Dixie Carter - 2013 Gooker Award Winner (Winner Turkey Dinner)!". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- RD Reynolds and Art0Donnell (February 5, 2015). "INDUCTION: Vince McMahon and the Brass Rings - 2014 Gooker Award Co-Winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Art0Donnell (February 5, 2015). "Induction: Bella vs. Bella - 2014 Gooker Award Co-winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Art0Donnell (February 11, 2016). "Induction: The Rusev-Lana-Dolph-Summer Rae Love Trapezoid - The 2015 Gooker Award Winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Reynolds, RD (January 26, 2017). "INDUCTION: WrestleMania 32 - 2016 Gooker Award Winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Art0Donnell (January 18, 2018). "Induction: Jinder Mahal, WWE Champion - The 2017 Gooker Award Winner (for real this time)". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- Art0Donnell (January 31, 2019). "Induction: WWE Crown Jewel – The 2018 Gooker Winner". WrestleCrap. Retrieved February 1, 2019.
- Reynolds, RD (August 20, 2015). "RD and Blade Show – 10th Anniversary". WrestleCrap. Retrieved 2016-01-18.
- "Category Archive for 'RD & Blade'". WrestleCrap. Retrieved 2016-01-18.
- Official WrestleCrap MySpace page
- Official Wrestling Hustle Podcast Directory
- 2018 |Wrestlers shocking death list|fix-attempted=yes }} WrestleCrap Radio Recaps
- Official WrestleCrap Radio MySpace page
- Blade Braxton's official MySpace page
- "Pick My Brain" interview with R. D. Reynolds at Armpit-Wrestling.com