Will Hay

William Thomson Hay FRAS (6 December 1888 – 18 April 1949) was an English comedian, actor, author, film director and amateur astronomer who came to notice for his theatrical sketch as a jocular schoolmaster, known as Dr. Muffin. The acts in which Hay performed the schoolmaster sketch became known as "The Fourth Form at St. Michael's". Hay toured with the act and appeared in the United States, Canada, Australia and South Africa. He famously performed the schoolmaster routine at the 1925 Royal Command Performance before King George V and Queen Mary.[1] From 1934 to 1943, he was a prolific film star in Britain and was ranked the third highest grossing star at the British Box Office in 1938, behind George Formby and Gracie Fields. He is widely regarded as one of the most prolific and influential British comedians of all-time.[2]

Hay worked with Gainsborough Pictures from 1935 to 1940, during which time he developed a partnership with Graham Moffatt, playing an insolent overweight schoolboy, and Moore Marriott as a toothless old man. Hay's 1937 film, with Moffatt and Marriott, Oh, Mr. Porter! was credited by The Times as being "a comic masterpiece of the British cinema",[3] while the writer Jimmy Perry cited the film as an influence on key character development for Dad's Army.[4]

Hay often portrayed incompetent authority figures who attempt to conceal their incompetence but whose true traits are gradually exposed. As well as being incompetent, his characters are often immoral; for example, a vicar involved in horse betting in Dandy Dick, a fraudster who lies about his career as a distinguished sea captain in Windbag the Sailor, and a prison warden, Dr Benjamin Twist, in Convict 99, who obtains his job under false pretenses.[5] He is often compared to W. C. Fields, who typically portrayed characters similar to those of Hay, being misanthropic, self-centered scoundrels who nevertheless remain sympathetic.[6]

Hay was also an amateur astronomer, and in 1933 gained fame for discovering a Great White Spot on Saturn. He built his own observatory and was a Fellow of the Royal Astronomical Society.

Early life

Hay was born at 23 Durham Street in Stockton-on-Tees, County Durham, England, to William Robert Hay (1851–1920) and his wife, Elizabeth (1859–1910) (née Ebden). Hay had a brother and three sisters. When Hay was less than a year old the family moved to Suffolk.[7][8] William Hay Snr's career as an engineer required the family to move frequently; firstly to Hemel Hempstead; then to London; and finally to Manchester, where his father established an engineering company. By his late teens, Hay Jnr. had become fluent in Italian, French and German and secured employment as an interpreter.[9]


Early career

Hay decided to become an actor when he was 21 after watching W. C. Fields perform a juggling act in Manchester. In the early years of the twentieth century Hay experienced some moderate success as a stand-up comedian and an after dinner speaker.[10] Hay's first professional job came when he was offered a contract to perform at a theatre in Belper.[10] He first performed his schoolmaster character in 1910 which he based upon a colleague of his sister, who was a teaching mistress.[9] The characterisation was initially performed in drag as a schoolmistress, but he transferred the character to a headmaster.[2]

In 1914 Hay began working with the impresario Fred Karno who had previously helped Stan Laurel and Charlie Chaplin achieve success. Hay worked with Karno for four years.[10]

Hay's schoolmaster sketches, known as "the fourth form at St Michaels", were popular in the 1920s, and he toured with them around the world. He enjoyed particular success in South Africa, Canada and the USA. His wife, Gladys, often played a schoolboy or the character Harbottle in his sketches. The Harbottle character was one of the most popular in Hay's act, a dim-witted, nearly deaf old man who is still in school because he's so backward.[2] The character later featured in Hay's films portrayed by Moore Marriott. In a 1976 interview, Val Guest who served as a screenwriter for many of Hay's films, recalled transposing Harbottle from school into other everyday situations.[2]

Hay performed the schoolmaster routine at the 1925 Royal Command Performance before King George V and Queen Mary. This was widely regarded as one of his most famous performances.[1]

Hay published a magazine piece entitled Philosophy of Laughter, in which he discussed the psychology of comedy. In the essay he rhetorically asks, "Why does every one of us laugh at seeing somebody else slapped in the face with a large piece of cold custard pie? Is it because we're all naturally cruel? Or is it because there's something inherently funny in custard pies? Or in faces? Or in throwing things? No, no, and no! The real reason why we laugh is because we are relieved. Because we are released from a sense of fear. Wherever we may happen to be – in the cinema, theatre, or music-hall – we tend to identify with the actors we are watching. So that when a custard pie is thrown we fear for a moment that it has been thrown at us. And then, immediately we realise that it hasn't hit us, we experience a feeling of relief, and we laugh".[11]

Elstree Studios

Hay had become interested in film making while touring in the United States in the 1920s, although, at the time he doubted he had a future in this field. Having returned to Britain, Hay started work at Elstree Studios in 1934 where he made three films, Those Were the Days, Radio Parade of 1935 and Dandy Dick.[2]

Gainsborough Pictures

Hay's work at Gainsborough was his most successful, and source of his reputation as a great comic actor. During this period he became one of the most prolific film stars in Britain. On three occasions, British film exhibitors voted him among the top ten box office stars in an annual poll run by the Motion Picture Herald. He was ranked 8th in 1936, 4th in 1937 and 3rd in 1938.[12]

His first film for the studio was Boys Will Be Boys, whose screenplay was written by Hay himself. The movie's satire on the public school system was loosely based on the Narkover vein of humour in the work of Daily Express columnist, Beachcomber. Hay's film was widely seen as subversive towards authority, and it was granted an 'A' (adult) certificate by the British Board of Film Classification.[5] Boys Will Be Boys is widely regarded as Hay's break-out film. Writing for The Spectator, Graham Greene described the film as "very amusing", and Hay's portrayal of Dr. Smart as "competent", though Green thought Claude Dampier's portrayal of Second Master Finch (Hay's adversary) was the film's "finest performance".[13] Many years later, the Radio Times Guide to Films gave Boys Will Be Boys three stars out of five, observing that the film contains "the blend of bluster and dishonesty that makes his films irresistible".[14]

During his time with Gainsborough Hay worked with Marcel Varnel, Val Guest, Charles Hawtrey, and Marriott Edgar, as well as Moore Marriott and Graham Moffatt, who were Hay's straight men in a number of his films. Moffatt played Albert, the overweight, insolent schoolboy reminiscent of Billy Bunter, while Marriott was the toothless old Harbottle. The trio appeared in six films together between 1936 and 1940, Windbag the Sailor, Oh, Mr. Porter!, Convict 99, Old Bones of the River, Ask a Policeman and Where's That Fire?.

Hay's 1937 film alongside Moffatt and Marriott, Oh, Mr. Porter! is often considered to be one of the greatest British comedy films of all-time. The British Film Institute included the film in its 360 Classic Feature Films list;[15] Variety magazine described the movie as "amusing, if over-long", noting that there was " no love interest to mar the comedy";[16] and the cult website TV Cream listed it at number 41 in its list of cinema's Top 100 Films.[17] The director Marcel Varnel considered the film as among his best work,[18] and it was described in 2006, by The Times in its obituary for writer Val Guest, as "a comic masterpiece of the British cinema".[19] Jimmy Perry, in his autobiography, wrote that the triumvirate of Captain Mainwaring, Corporal Jones and Private Pike in Dad's Army was inspired by watching Oh, Mr Porter.[20]

Both Moffatt and Marriott were absent from Hay's 1938 film, Hey! Hey! USA with American comedy actor Edgar Kennedy being cast as Hay's sidekick instead, the film was a somewhat unsuccessful attempt to crack the American market.[21] In many of his films, Hay wore a wig, which made it appear as if he was balding.[6]

Hay decided to break up the partnership with Moffatt and Marriott after their 1940 film Where's That Fire? due to his concern that their act was becoming repetitive.[6] Hay was known to dislike working with Moffatt and Marriott, describing their partnership as "a three legged stool".[22] He had also expressed concern that Moore Marriott who portrayed Harbottle received a bigger reaction from audiences than he did.[6] He had been seeking to break up their partnership in the years prior, it was only due to his film Hey! Hey! USA being somewhat unsuccessful that the writers and producers successfully talked him into bringing Moffatt and Marriott back.[10]

Ealing Studios

Hay left Gainsborough and began working with Ealing Studios in 1940, in an attempt to break up his partnership with Graham Moffatt and Moore Marriott. Claude Hulbert and Charles Hawtrey were Hay's sidekicks in his first film for Ealing, The Ghost of St Michael's (1941). Both would return to act with Hay in respective films, Hawtrey in The Goose Steps Out (1942) and Hulbert in Hay's final film, My Learned Friend (1943). John Mills, who had appeared in Hay's first film, Those Were the Days returned to act as his sidekick in The Black Sheep of Whitehall. The Goose Steps Out (1942) for Ealing was an effective piece of anti-Nazi slapstick, in the film, Hay acts as a British spy posing as a Nazi official and teaches Nazi students about British customs. When lecturing them on this topic, he tells the students that the V sign (often used in Britain as an insult) is a mark of respect, and instructs the class to make a synchronised V sign to a portrait of Adolf Hitler. This scene is often considered one of the most iconic from a British comedy film.[5]

During Hay's tenure with Ealing he was credited as a director in three of his films, The Black Sheep of Whitehall, The Goose Steps Out and My Learned Friend. In all three, he co-directed with Basil Dearden. In 1942, he starred in a short information film, Go to Blazes alongside Thora Hird and Muriel George. The film was set during the Blitz and his role was a dim-witted father who tried unsuccessfully to defuse a bomb which had landed near his house, the bomb is only defused through the help of his daughter, portrayed by Hird.[23] Also in 1942, he made an appearance in the propaganda film, The Big Blockade among other prolific actors of the time, including Leslie Banks, John Mills and Michael Redgrave.[24]

His final film, My Learned Friend in 1943 has been described as a masterpiece of black comedy and has been cited as paving the way for the future Ealing comedy films Kind Hearts and Coronets (1949) and The Ladykillers (1955).[25] Due to ailing health, My Learned Friend was Hay's final film.[6] The plot of the film was Hay in the role of an incompetent barrister being haunted by a serial killer and an ex-client (Mervyn Johns) who seeks to kill him.

Hay was scheduled to star in another film for Ealing in 1943, Bob's Your Uncle, but his diagnosis of cancer prevented him from proceeding.[26]

Hay's tenure with Ealing was a box office success and his films were critically acclaimed, but not as funny as those made at Gainsborough with Moffatt and Marriott.[2]

Radio career

The half-hour weekly Will Hay Programme began in August 1944, and was broadcast live from the BBC Paris Theatre in Lower Regent Street. With him in his schoolmaster role, were his pupils, Charles Hawtrey playing the cheeky Smart, John Clark as the class swot D'arcy Minor, and Billy Nicholls playing the dumb Beckett. The series lasted for four months and was cancelled, it is said, due to Hay's dispute with the BBC over the quality of the scripts. Just before Christmas, the show went live at the Victoria Palace for six weeks. The sketch was performed one more time at a gathering of variety entertainers at midnight on 4 May 1945 (4 days before VE Day) before the Royal Family and many military notables. This was at a private function at the Life Guards barracks in Windsor. It was not publicised in the newspapers due to security concerns. Hay's character during his radio series was called Dr. Muffin, a name chosen so that the students could mock him with the name "Old Crumpet".[27]


Aside from his day job as a comedian, Hay was a dedicated and respected amateur astronomer. He constructed a personal observatory in his garden in Mill Hill and built a glider in 1909. In June 1932 he joined the British Astronomical Association, in November of the same year he became a Fellow of the Royal Astronomical Society.[28][29] He is noted for having discovered a Great White Spot on the planet Saturn in 1933.[30] The spot lasted for a few months and then faded away. He also measured the positions of comets with a micrometer he built himself, and designed and built a blink comparator. He wrote the book Through My Telescope in 1935, which had a foreword by Sir Richard Gregory, formerly Emeritus Professor of Astronomy at Queen's College, London.

Hay kept his career in astronomy separate from his comedy career and published Through My Telescope under the name of W.T. Hay, and using the same title when giving lectures on astronomy.[2] Hay was an advocate for education on astronomy and considered those who had an interest in astronomy "the only men who see life in its true proportion". In a 1933 interview with the Daily Mail he stated "If we were all astronomers, there'd be no more war."[31] He was a friend of William Herbert Steavenson, who would go on to become the President of the Royal Astronomical Society in 1957.[31]

Just before Hay died, a few items of his equipment were donated to the British Astronomical Association.[32]. He also has an asteroid named in his honour - Asteroid 3125 Hay.[33]

Personal life, health issues and death

Hay married Gladys Perkins (1889–1982) in 1907,[34] whom he had known since he was 15,[35] but legally separated on 18 November 1935. However, they never divorced and Gladys cited the reason for this as she was a Roman Catholic.[10] They had two daughters and a son: Gladys Elspeth Hay (1909–1979), William Edward Hay (1913–1995)[36] and Joan A. Hay (1917–1975).[37] Following his separation from Gladys in 1935, he was in a long-term relationship with Randi Kopstadt, a native of Norway.[10]

Off-screen, Hay was described as being something of an eccentric, and a very serious and private man, and some thought he may have had a dark side due to his demeanour.[5] Peter Ustinov, who made his film debut in The Goose Steps Out as a straight man to Hay, said in a 1990 interview when asked about working with him "Well, Will Hay wasn't very funny but I found that very few comics are"; he also said "And Will Hay was always wrapped in a blanket at certain hours and had his tea, and we all stopped talking while he was having his tea, and then we went on shooting. I don't remember him saying anything memorable, nothing I could remember at all. He was very funny when you saw him on the screen, but in life all those people are very, very strange."[38]

He was known to be a hypochondriac, and would often complain of illness to his colleagues when working.[2]

In 1931 and 1940 Hay served two non-consecutive terms as "King Rat" of the entertainment charity the Grand Order of Water Rats.

Hay was a passionate aviator, and gave flying lessons to Amy Johnson.[39]

In 1946 while on holiday, Hay suffered a stroke which left the right side of his body crippled and also affected his speech, Hay was told by his doctors that he would in all likelihood only make a partial recovery.[10] Following his stroke, he spent time in South Africa on the advice of his doctors, because of the climate.[2] However, his health had improved slightly by the following year when Hay had plans to become a film producer. However, in 1947, his friend Marcel Varnel, who had directed many of Hay's films, died in a car accident, and Hay postponed his plans.[10]

He made his last public appearance on Good Friday (15 April) 1949. Hay died on 18 April 1949 at his flat in Chelsea, London three days later following a further stroke. He was 60 years old and is buried in Streatham Park Cemetery, London.[40]

Those who were present at Hay's final appearance described him as showing no sign of illness, and said he had discussed his plans for the future.[10]


Comedians who have cited Hay as an influence include Ken Dodd,[41] Eric Morecambe, Tommy Cooper, Harry Worth,[21] Harry Enfield, Jimmy Perry and David Croft.[4] Hay was also an influence on Tony Hancock, who often portrayed characters of a format similar to that of Hay, typically impostors who tried to hide their true identity.[5] Ronnie Barker also cited Hay as an influence, and in 1976 hosted a documentary on BBC Radio that discussed Hay's life and career.[2]


The Will Hay Appreciation Society was founded in 2009 by British artist Tom Marshall and aims to preserve Hay's legacy and bring his work to a new generation of fans. As of June 2019, the organisation has over 4200 members.[42] The Will Hay Appreciation Society unveiled a memorial bench to Will Hay, Moore Marriott and Graham Moffatt in October 2018, in Cliddesden, Hampshire the filming location for 'Buggleskelly' in Oh, Mr. Porter!. The bench was unveiled by Pete Waterman.[43]

The humour of Hay's films has been described as subversive and similar to that of fellow English comedian Frank Randle. His films are often characterised as exhibiting traits of Anti-authoritarianism and having a satirical approach towards how authority figures are portrayed. This is notable with Hay himself, who often played an incompetent authority figure who struggled not to be found out, but whose idiocy was discovered by those around him.[5]

In 2009 a posthumous biography of Hay by Graham Rinaldi was published with a foreword by Ken Dodd. Hay never published an autobiography during his lifetime; however, when ill in the 1940s, he had begun writing one, entitled I Enjoyed Every Minute. Excerpts from this unpublished autobiography were included in the 2009 book.[41]

Roy Hudd defined Hay as the "supreme master" of sketch comedy.[2]


See also


  1. "The Fourth Form At St. Michaels Will Hay & His Scholars". A.J.H. Computer Services. Retrieved 10 May 2017.
  2. "Will Hay – Master of Comedy". YouTube. BBC Radio 4. 2 June 1976. Retrieved 10 May 2017.
  3. The Times 16 May 2006
  4. "Jimmy Perry obituary: Creator of Dad's Army who used his own life experiences in much-loved sitcom". The Independent. 24 October 2016. Retrieved 9 May 2017.
  5. "The Essay, British Film Comedians: Will Hay". BBC Radio 3. 13 April 2015. Retrieved 9 May 2017.
  6. "Will Hay: the lost master of British comedy". The Daily Telegraph. 16 January 2009. Retrieved 10 May 2017.
  7. 1891 UK census: RG12/1494 f.56 p.47 & p.48 – 192 Clapham Road, Lowestoft, Suffolk
  8. GRO Register of Births: MAR 1889 10a 49 STOCKTON – William Thomson Hay
  9. "Will Hay: Britain's bumbling star of the screen and skies. Page 1". The Register. 25 May 2015. Retrieved 6 May 2017.
  10. "Will Hay". Stockton-on-Tees Borough Council. Retrieved 12 September 2017.
  11. "Will Hay: Britain's bumbling star of the screen and skies. Page 2". The Register. 25 May 2015. Retrieved 6 May 2017.
  12. "PICTURES and PERSONALITIES". The Mercury. Hobart, Tas. 10 April 1937. p. 5 National Library of Australia. Retrieved 27 April 2012.
  13. Greene, Graham (23 August 1935). "Where's George?/The Great God Gold/Boys Will Be Boys/The Murder Man". The Spectator. (reprinted in: John Russel, Taylor, ed. (1980). The Pleasure Dome. p. 16. ISBN 0192812866.)
  14. Radio Times Guide to Films (2004). p.187
  15. "Top 100 Movie Lists – BFI's 360 Classic Feature Films". Archived from the original on 27 October 2009. Retrieved 16 March 2007.CS1 maint: unfit url (link)
  16. "Oh, Mr. Porter! Movie Review". Variety. 1 January 1937. Archived from the original on 24 October 2007.
  17. TV Cream's Top 100 Films
  18. So You Want To Be In Pictures: The Autobiography of Val Guest
  19. The Times, 16 May 2006
  20. James Perry, A Stupid Boy (2002), p. 100
  21. "Will Hay: Britain's bumbling star of the screen and skies. Page 3". The Register. 25 May 2015. Retrieved 6 May 2017.
  22. "Moore Marriott (1885 - 1949)". British Pictures. Retrieved 10 May 2017.
  23. "Go to Blazes (1942)". BFI Screen Online. Retrieved 10 May 2017.
  24. "The Big Blockade (1942)". The British Film Institute. Retrieved 10 May 2017.
  25. "Will Hay's new direction: My Learned Friend". The British Film Institute. 1 June 2015. Retrieved 11 May 2017.
  26. Trade Advert - The Cinema 14 July 1942
  27. "How Tickled Am I? Series 2 Episode 6 – Will Hay". BBC Radio 7. 2008. Retrieved 6 May 2017.
  28. "1932JBAA...42..313. Page 313". articles.adsabs.harvard.edu. Retrieved 22 May 2019.
  29. "1932MNRAS..93....1. Page 1". articles.adsabs.harvard.edu. Retrieved 22 May 2019.
  30. Hay, W.T. (1933). "The spot on Saturn". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 94: 85. Bibcode:1933MNRAS..94...85H. doi:10.1093/mnras/94.1.85. Retrieved 11 May 2017.
  31. Mobberley, Martin P.; Goward, Kenneth J. (April 2009). "Will Hay (1888-1949) and his telescopes". Journal of the British Astronomical Association. 119 (2): 67–81. Bibcode:2009JBAA..119...67M.
  32. "1948JBAA...58..235. Page 250". articles.adsabs.harvard.edu. Retrieved 22 May 2019.
  33. Peebles, Curtis (26 April 2016). Asteroids: A History. Smithsonian Institution. ISBN 9781944466046. Retrieved 11 May 2017.
  34. GRO Register of Marriages: DEC 1907 8d 287 SALFORD – William Thomson Hay = Gladys Perkins
  35. Hockey, Thomas (2009). The Biographical Encyclopedia of Astronomers. Springer Publishing. ISBN 978-0-387-31022-0. Retrieved 22 August 2012.
  36. GRO Register of Births: SEP 1913 8d 120 SALFORD – William E. Hay
  37. GRO Register of Births: SEP 1917 8d 64 SALFORD – Joan A. Hay
  38. "Peter Ustinov: The Guardian Interview". BFI Screen Online. 7 April 1990. Retrieved 11 May 2017.
  39. "Local history: Amy Johnson", BBC Humberside, 24 September 2014, accessed 2 July 2017.
  40. GRO Register of Deaths: JUN 1949 5c 251 CHELSEA – William T. Hay, aged 60
  41. Rinaldi, Graham (2009). Will Hay. Tomahawk Press. ISBN 9780955767012. Retrieved 11 May 2017.
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.