The Wehrmacht: History, Myth, Reality

The Wehrmacht: History, Myth, Reality is a 2002 book by German historian Wolfram Wette which discusses the Myth of the clean Wehrmacht. The original German-language book was translated into five languages; the English edition was published in 2007 by Harvard University Press. The book builds on Omer Bartov's 1985 study The Eastern Front, 1941–1945: German Troops and the Barbarisation of Warfare. The book received a positive reception.

The Wehrmacht: History, Myth, Reality
AuthorWolfram Wette
Original titleDie Wehrmacht. Feindbilder, Vernichtungskrieg, Legenden [The Wehrmacht: Images of the Enemy, War of Extermination, Legends]
TranslatorDeborah Lucas Schneider
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish, German
GenreHistory; Historiography
PublisherS. Fischer Verlag (German edition)
Harvard University Press (English edition)
Publication date
2002
Published in English
2007
Media typePrint
ISBN978-0-674-02577-6

Concept

The book was first published in German with a title that translates as The Wehrmacht: Images of the Enemy, War of Extermination, Legends. According to The Atlantic, it shows that "the Wehrmacht—and not, as postwar accounts by German generals would have it, merely the SS—freely and even eagerly joined in murder and genocide".[1]

The book complements earlier studies that focused on the average soldier and in turn discusses the complicity of the highest levels of the Wehrmacht. Wette discusses the commanding officers and colonels, demonstrating that they not only knew about but successfully created the myth of the clean Wehrmacht.[2]

Reception

Reviewing the work, Geoffrey Megargee notes that "until Wette's work, there was no concise, general survey on the Wehrmacht's crimes, at least for an English-speaking audience. Thus, his work fills a significant gap in the literature." Megargee notes that although Wette makes the Wehrmacht leadership fully accountable for war crimes the case is less clear for many of the lower ranks and Wette concedes further research is needed.[3] Lee Baker, in reviewing Wette's book for the Society for Military History, notes that it is not about "the average soldier's descent into barbarism". Instead, it is "a study of the path trod by the commanding officers... who formulated policy and created an environment in which mass murder could occur."[2]

Steve Choe of the University of Iowa, in reviewing the book, wrote "It aims to debunk the legend of the Wehrmacht's "clean hands," a legend that exculpates the Germany army from any misdeed during World War Two" and "Wette delivers a devastating blow to this set of myths through careful research and astute interpretation".[4]

Stephen G. Fritz writes "Leading German military historian Wolfram Wette has written the equivalent of an extended lawyer's brief arguing for a fundamental revision of the popular conception of the role of the German army during World War II" and "his arguments will provide a powerful corrective to the outdated view that Wehrmacht leaders were dragged unwillingly into complicity in Nazi-mandated crimes."[5]

Publishers Weekly wrote "The conventional wisdom that the German army in WWII fought a relatively clean fight, unsullied by the atrocities committed by the Nazi SS, has recently been challenged—and largely demolished. This probing study explores the rise and fall of that myth in the light of scholarship debunking it".[6]

Donald Detwiler, of the Southern Illinois University, considered Wette's work "a landmark in German military historiography", but pointed out the English-language translation is flawed with several errors and was guilty of "often failing to convey if not distorting significant nuances in his [Welte's] treatment of complex issues."[7]

See also

References

Citations

Bibliography

This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.