The play was first produced at Detroit Repertory Theatre from November 2006 to January 2007. The production was directed by Bruce E. Millan. It drew together a cast of luminaries including the grande doyenne of Detroit theater, Henrietta Hermelin, best known for her role as an elderly blind woman in June August's comedy Coming to Life. Hermelin, who portrayed Dame Lucretia Bankmore, the elderly real estate mogul bent upon chopping down the poplar, was nominated for a Wilde Award for Best Supporting Actress. Michael Joseph also returned to the Detroit Rep, where he'd previously delivered an award-winning performance as the poet Langston Hughes in Hannibal of the Alps. Other notable performers included veteran regional actors Leah Smith and Annie Cross. Imani Turner made her Michigan debut as the tree-struck daughter.
The Detroit Free Press described the play as "fanciful" and "sharply funny." Donald Calamia in Detroit Pride Source called the play an "insightful poke at many of our cherished beliefs and institutions."
- "Daughters in Love Fuel Mom's Dismay," Detroit Free Press, November 14, 2006.
- 'Sappy Satire Takes Root at Detroit Rep" Detroit Pride Source, November 15, 2006.
- "Tale of Tree Love Receives Top Honors," Detroit Metro Times, January 2007.